Day Hagan Research Update




Supply and demand measures suggest that there is more demand than there is supply of stock (i.e., more buyers than sellers).


Neil Leeson


December 16, 2016


The chart below illustrates the strong demand for U.S. stocks relative to the supply. The NDR Volume Demand indicator is based on the longer-term moving average of the total volume of advancing issues in the broad U.S. equity market and NDR Volume Supply is a measurement of the volume in the declining issues.  The bottom clip of this chart (green line) is the spread between the two series. When the spread is increasing it suggests that buyers are outpacing sellers of stocks. A spread that is declining is a sign of caution. Simply put, this measure tells us if buyers or sellers are in control of the market. And clearly the buyers are in control.

S&P 500 Index vs. NDR Supply and Demand with Spread

To be clear, the demand/supply spread is not a timing indicator and should not be relied on as such. I consider it both a sentiment and an overbought/oversold indicator. Nonetheless, this measure is getting extended based on historical levels and will be an important input in our investment decisions going forward (watching for a change in trend). But for now, as long as there is more demand for stocks than supply, the market can churn higher, despite valuation, monetary or sentiment concerns.


Like the demand/supply spread, several other sentiment measures are at extremely optimistic levels based on historical analysis. For example, the sentiment composite in the bottom clip of the chart below comprises multiple indicators (sentiment polls, put/call ratios, and mutual fund assets) that have historically been good in evaluating longer-term investor sentiment. As shown, while sentiment is high, it can go much higher before indicating trouble for the equity market. With sentiment it typically pays to go with the crowd until sentiment starts to reverse. Nonetheless, sentiment and the demand/supply spread suggest that the upside may be limited from here and that investors should tread cautiously.

NDR Crowd Sentiment Poll Chart


As we have mentioned before, the U.S. dollar is extremely overvalued based on historical purchasing power measures. However, the PowerShares U.S. Dollar ETF (symbol: UUP) is nowhere near longer-term overbought extremes (below). This longer-term measure did signal extremes in early 2015. But since this indicator uses year-over-year historical data, the overbought condition was worked off and now the fund is neutral (neither overbought nor oversold).

Total Return Data Used

As we have written about extensively in the past, the dollar has been a key factor influencing investors' decisions for several years now. Keep in mind that currencies, especially the dollar, are often reflections of the relative global central bank policies that are in place—as well as future actions that are being "touted" by central bank mouthpieces. If a central bank wants to weaken their country's currency in an effort to spur growth and increase exports, they would seek to lower interest rates. If they wanted to strengthen their currency, they would seek to slow down growth (below inflation-inducing levels) and increase their interest rates.

At this point, the U.S. Federal Reserve has hinted that they want to "normalize rates" in an effort to ensure that we have the quintessential Goldilocks economy (not too hot/not too cold). Nonetheless, their efforts are bolstering the dollar's strength, which is an unwanted side effect of a "normalizing" policy. The stronger dollar is a negative 1) for U.S.-domiciled companies' mulitnational earnings and 2) the cost of our exports (the strong dollar makes our exports more expensive and U.S. exporters are at a disadvantage when competing in the global marketplace). So far, the strong dollar has not deterred investor demand for U.S. equities.

Not only are U.S. investors buying, foreigners have come back into the U.S. stock markets. While the data in the bottom clip of the chart below is only through the third quarter, it clearly shows foreign buying of U.S. stocks after several quarters of net selling. And why not, as foreigners have been gaining from both U.S. equity and dollar appreciation this year. Money goes where it is treated best, and clearly that is into dollar-based assets.

Foreign Net Purchases of U.S. Equities


While dollar strength is working for foreign investors in U.S. markets, it is not working for dollar-based investments in several developed foreign market ETFs. We currently own emerging market and Asian ETFs that do not hedge the foreign currency exposure. And over the past month, the underlying currencies of these two ETFs (VWO and AAXJ) have actually been strengthening versus the dollar, helping the returns. It has been the weakness in the equity holdings that have hurt these funds. Nonetheless, we are maintaining our exposure to both of these funds as long as flows remain supportive (below)—a sign of investor demand.

Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF (VWO)

In addition to positive flows, emerging market relative earnings growth is clearly more favorable than developed market earnings growth as represented in the MSCI World Index. As I outlined in last week's publication, overall valuation metrics show greater potential for emerging than developed markets, and we think valuation differentials will come into play in the years to come.

MSCI World Index vs. Y/Y Change in Relative Earnings Growth

In sum, demand remains a dominant factor in U.S. equity markets and has pushed U.S. investor sentiment to optimistic extremes. Elevated levels of euphoria are a warning sign that the upside may be limited and that there is a possibility of some near-term weakness which could remedy the situation.

We continue to look at the markets from a multifactor approach, which has reduced our expectations for further U.S. equity market strength. On one hand we have economic, valuation, sentiment and monetary indicators suggesting that U.S. equities have gone too far too fast. On the other hand we have trend, money flows and demand indicators that continue to favor further strength. While we continue to side with how the markets are acting and not how they should be acting, we remain very cautious with preservation of capital in mind.

Have a wonderful week,

Neil Leeson
Day Hagan Investment Committee Consultant

Day Hagan Asset Management

Written 12.15.2016

Disclosure: The data and analysis contained herein are provided "as is" and without warranty of any kind, either expressed or implied. Day Hagan Asset Management (DHAM), any of its affiliates or employees, or any third party data provider, shall not have any liability for any loss sustained by anyone who has relied on the information contained in any Day Hagan Asset Management literature or marketing materials. All opinions expressed herein are subject to change without notice, and you should always obtain current information and perform due diligence before investing. DHAM, accounts that DHAM or its affiliated companies manage, or their respective shareholders, directors, officers and/or employees, may have long or short positions in the securities discussed herein and may purchase or sell such securities without notice. DHAM uses and has historically used various methods to evaluate investments which, at times, produce contradictory recommendations with respect to the same securities. When evaluating the results of prior DHAM recommendations or DHAM performance rankings, one should also consider that DHAM may modify the methods it uses to evaluate investment opportunities from time to time, that model results do not impute or show the compounded adverse effect of transactions costs or management fees or reflect actual investment results, that some model results do not reflect actual historical recommendations, and that investment models are necessarily constructed with the benefit of hindsight. For this and for many other reasons, the performance of DHAM's past recommendations and model results are not a guarantee of future results. The securities mentioned in this document may not be eligible for sale in some states or countries, nor be suitable for all types of investors; their value and income they produce may fluctuate and/or be adversely affected by exchange rates, interest rates or other factors.

Day Hagan Asset Management and Mutual Funds ©   |  Disclosures  |  Site Design by Lee Towle Designs